Perspective: Leave the Ramayana You Know at Home and Enjoy This Movie

There are two very different ways to approach Ramayana: Rise of a Legend (Part 1), Namit Malhotra’s much-discussed cinematic retelling of the epic. If you go in looking for an entertaining spectacle with an uplifting message about honor and dharma, you are unlikely to be disappointed. But the moment you start looking for the Ramayana you grew up with, disappointment, and perhaps even anger, may follow.

It would have been a miracle if a flashy modern retelling of one of Sanatan Dharma’s most revered epics had not generated controversy.

After all, the sensibilities surrounding Valmiki’s Ramayana, a sacred text, are fundamentally at odds with modern moviemaking and its computer-generated effects, IMAX screens, 3D experiences, and box-office ambitions. One is a timeless call to dharmic values such as vairagya (detachment); the other is built on the seductive tools of mayavi bhog (the illusory pleasures of a fantasy world).

Producer Namit Malhotra

Looking for the sacred in the inherently commercial, highly rajasic (passion-driven) world of bombastic light, sound, and special effects is a fool’s errand.

You will save yourself a great deal of heartache, and likely enjoy the film’s close-to-three-and-a-half-hour runtime a lot more, if you walk in with a clean slate. Leave the Ramayana you know at home.

Who Made This Movie and Why?

Before asking how faithfully the film represents the original scripture, I wanted to know about the people behind it and their motives.

The political appropriation of Hinduism in recent years, along with a growing trend of ideologically driven filmmaking, has made me skeptical of such ventures. Knowing little about producer Namit Malhotra or his motivations for undertaking such a massive project, I wondered whether this might be yet another politically charged production in the mold of The Kashmir Files or The Kerala Story.

It was reassuring to learn that Malhotra is the founder of Prime Focus and the CEO of DNEG, one of the world’s leading visual effects studios. DNEG has won eight Academy Awards for Best Visual Effects, for films such as Interstellar, Blade Runner 2049, and Dune. Whatever else one may think of this adaptation, its producer clearly understands the craft of large-scale cinematic storytelling.

Likewise, director Nitesh Tiwari comes with considerable credibility, having directed acclaimed films such as Dangal and Chhichhore. With filmmakers of this caliber at the helm, I decided to contribute my tiny share to the movie’s box-office success and judge the work on its own merits.

Ram Baan: Where the Film Hits the Mark

Malhotra’s expertise in creating grand cinematic worlds is on full display here. Nearly every frame strives for epic scale and, more often than not, succeeds.

Some critics disagree. Reviewing the film for The Quint, Suchin Mehrotra argued that it “lives entirely in service of its bigness and digital shininess.” RogerEbert.com called it an “overproduced, underdeveloped boondoggle.” Siddharth Adlakha of IGN criticized its “clunky action” and “eye-sore CGI.”

I find these criticisms puzzling. For those taking issue with the “digital shininess” (read: overreliance on CGI), I wonder what they were expecting. A slice-of-life drama about Mumbai street rappers? A grounded social realist story set around a panchayat office in rural Uttar Pradesh?

The very premise of the Ramayana demands grandeur. This is a story of devas, asuras, celestial weapons, flying chariots, shape-shifters, and the mighty Garuda. So why complain about overproduction? Would the same critics call The Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, or The Avengers overproduced, when their special effects are every bit as grandiose as those of Ramayana, if not more so?

Granted, the CGI may lack the polish of a slick sci-fi epic set a few hundred years in the future. But form must serve function. The eyesore in Ramayana is not the CGI but the characters it was meant to create: ghoulish asuras.

I found the film’s visuals stunning and effective. The tender moment between Ram and Sita in the quiet, verdant forest had the aura of a beautiful painting. The scene when the audience is first introduced to the royal palace of Mithila, Sita’s home, had all the splendor of a grand theatrical production. And when Ram’s baan (arrow) raised a towering wall of whirling wind around Sita, Ram, and Lakshman, the effect was appropriately awe-inspiring.

Combined with the musical talents of Hans Zimmer and A.R. Rahman, the film is a feast for the eyes and ears. For those looking for pure moviegoing entertainment, Ramayana delivers.

Yash (left) as Ravana and Ranbir Kapoor as Ram in this age-old tale of the victory of good over evil.

It’s a Movie, Not a Scripture

When I first took an interest in the film, social media algorithms saturated my feeds with reviews, podcasts, reactions, and debates. At first, praise seemed to dominate the conversation. Viewers celebrated the visual spectacle, the action sequences, and Yash’s commanding screen presence as Ravana.

Soon, however, the tide appeared to shift. Every aspect of the film came under intense scrutiny: the casting, the script, the choice of source material, the treatment of individual characters, and which version of the Ramayana it chose to privilege.

Some of this criticism is entirely fair. Much of it, however, strikes me as inevitable. There are many versions of Ramayana across regions, languages, centuries, and traditions. It is simply impossible to create a single adaptation that satisfies everyone. A filmmaker tackling a work of this magnitude must be granted some degree of creative freedom, without which adaptation becomes impossible.

Where the Filmmakers Cross the Lakshman Rekha

Yet creative freedom has limits. When adapting one of the most sacred and influential texts in Hindu civilization, filmmakers are duty-bound to keep the story’s core moral architecture intact. Embellishing minor details for movie magic is one thing. Tampering with the very crux of this revered tale is another.

The most serious criticism leveled against the film is that it becomes, in effect, a “Ravanayana” rather than a Ramayana, because it glorifies Ravana and whitewashes his lust, hubris, and tyranny. This is a serious enough transgression that cannot be written off as cinematic license.

Director Nitesh Tiwari

Yes, Ravana was a brilliant Vedic scholar, a gifted musician, and an ardent devotee of Shiva. But he was also consumed by lust, arrogance, and power. I admit I was taken aback to see him portrayed as a virtuous defender of women’s modesty, as shown when he challenges his brother-in-law, Vidyutjihva, to a duel after finding him intoxicated and misbehaving with a dasi (female attendant). Not only is this episode absent from the traditional narrative, but it fundamentally alters Ravana’s moral character, turning a toxic womanizer into a chivalrous defender of women. (And if you are wondering why he did not violate Sita after abducting her: it was only for fear of a curse. After he assaulted the celestial nymph Rambha, her betrothed, Nalakubara, cursed him: if he ever again forced himself on an unwilling woman, his head would shatter into seven pieces.)

Worse is his depiction as the righteous leader of an oppressed people. This characterization, which transforms the epic’s main antagonist into a misunderstood hero, is squarely antithetical to the Ravana of tradition. Across virtually all major versions, he embodies adharma.

That is why his effigy is still burned across India and the Hindu diaspora every Dussehra. The ritual is a timeless reminder that no matter how great one’s knowledge, talent, or power, ego and adharma ultimately lead to destruction.

When Ravana’s flaws are softened or rationalized, the central message of the Ramayana itself risks becoming blurred. The story is not merely about competing clans — asuras vs. devas, as shown (incorrectly) in the film. It is about the triumph of dharma over adharma.

A Ramayana for Gen Z and a Global Audience?

And yet, after all these criticisms, I find myself returning to a larger question. Can this film still serve a meaningful purpose?

If there is any hope of keeping India’s sacred stories alive for future generations, what better way than to recast them in a format Gen Z might actually consume? Packaged as an action-packed fantasy thriller, Malhotra’s Ramayana may be the only kind of telling that can reach not just India’s youth but global audiences as well.

Malhotra and Tiwari have not claimed theirs is the definitive Ramayana; the film opens with a disclaimer that “the Ramayana has no one teller.” As a fantasy epic with blockbuster production values, it could serve as an entry point for audiences who would never pick up Valmiki’s text, attend a Ram katha, or sit through a traditional retelling. Many young viewers, especially outside India, may encounter the story of Ram, Sita, Lakshman, and Ravana for the very first time through this film.

It is this initiation, however imperfect, that may kindle an interest in dharma and righteousness, and a curiosity about the living tradition from which the story emerges.

The danger, of course, is that audiences mistake the movie for scripture. The opportunity is that they do not stop with the adaptation. Perhaps that is the question by which this film should ultimately be judged: not whether it perfectly retells the Ramayana, but whether it inspires a new generation to discover the Ramayana for themselves.

Archives

LEAVE A REPLY